Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016

Europaudvalget 2015-16
Rådsmøde 3458 - almindelige anl.
Offentligt

Council of the

European Union

7101/16

(OR. en)

PRESSE 17

PR CO 17

OUTCOME OF THE COUNCIL MEETING

3458th Council meeting

General Affairs

Brussels, 15 March 2016

President

Bert Koenders

Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands

PRESS

Rue de la Loi 175 B – 1048 BRUSSELS Tel.: +32 (0)2 281 6319 / 6319 Fax: +32 (0)2 281 8026

[email protected] http://www.consilium.europa.eu/press

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

CONTENTS

ITEMS DEBATED

Preparation for the March European Council ...................................................................................... 3

European Semester ............................................................................................................................... 3

Agreement on better law-making ......................................................................................................... 4

Cohesion policy: investments for growth and jobs .............................................................................. 4

OTHER ITEMS APPROVED

GENERAL AFFAIRS

JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS

–

EU emergency support for Greece ........................................................................................................................ 12

Schengen Evaluation Mechanism - Belgium ......................................................................................................... 12

Schengen Evaluation Mechanism - Sweden .......................................................................................................... 12

FOOD LAW

–

Food additives and food flavourings ..................................................................................................................... 13

TRANSPORT

–

International Maritime Organisation: positions to be adopted on behalf of the EU .............................................. 14

EMPLOYMENT

–

EURES .................................................................................................................................................................. 15

CUSTOMS UNION

–

Moldova - Euro-Mediterranean agreement - Rules of origin ................................................................................ 15



Where declarations, conclusions or resolutions have been formally adopted by the Council, this is indicated

in the heading for the item concerned and the text is placed between quotation marks.

 

Documents for which references are given in the text are available on the Council's Internet site

(http://www.consilium.europa.eu).

 

Acts adopted with statements for the Council minutes which may be released to the public are indicated by

an asterisk; these statements are available on the Council's Internet site or may be obtained from the Press

Office.

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

ITEMS DEBATED

Preparation for the March European Council

The Council examined draft conclusions for the European Council meeting to be held on 17-

18 March, prepared by the President of the European Council, Donald Tusk, in cooperation with the

Netherlands presidency and the Commission.

The European Council is due to focus on:

–

migration, following the EU-Turkey summit on 7 March 2016

European Semester/single market

other items

annotated draft agenda

was discussed by the Council on 16 February 2016.

European Semester

The Council took note of a

presidency synthesis report

on the contributions of seven Council

configurations involved in the current European Semester exercise: the Economic and Financial

Affairs Council, the Employment, Social Policy, Health and Consumer Affairs Council, the

Competitiveness Council, the Transport, Telecommunications and Energy Council, the

Environment Council, the Education, Youth, Culture and Sport Council and the Justice and Home

Affairs Council.

The report emphasises that pressing ahead with an ambitious jobs and growth agenda remains

crucial to sustain the economic recovery in Europe, which is still fragile.

The Council also held a thematic debate on better governance and the quality of public

administrations.

The European Semester involves simultaneous monitoring of the member states' fiscal, economic

and employment policies during a six-month period every year. In the light of the guidance

provided by the European Council, the member states will prepare their national reform

programmes (economic and employment policies) and stability or convergence programmes (fiscal

policies) for this year.

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

Agreement on better law-making

The Council adopted the interinstitutional agreement on better law-making.

For details, see Council

press release.

Ministers also approved the

Council arrangements on annual programming

which translate the

provisions of the interinstitutional agreement into a set of concrete practical steps and indicative

timelines. Ministers also exchanged views on programming.

In accordance with the interinstitutional agreement, the Commission consults both the Council and

the Parliament before adopting its annual work programme and takes their views into account. In

addition, drawing on the Commission's annual work programme, the three institutions will identify

joint legislative priorities for the following year.

Council website on better law-making http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/better-

regulation/

Cohesion policy: investments for growth and jobs

The Council took note of a Commission communication

"Investing in jobs and growth -

maximising the contribution of European Structural and Investment Funds".

The communication

provides an overview of the main results of negotiations between member states' authorities and the

Commission on their investment programmes following the reform of the European structural and

investment funds.

The Council adopted the following conclusions on the Commission communication (6334/16):

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

"THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION:

(1)

RECALLING that the mission of Cohesion Policy is to strengthen its economic, social and

territorial cohesion and, in particular, to reduce disparities between the levels of

development of the various regions as set out in Article 174 of Treaty on the Functioning

of the European Union;

WELCOMES the highly anticipated communication from the European Commission:

"Investing in jobs and growth – maximising the contributions of European Structural and

Investment Funds" provided under Article 16 of the Common Provisions

Regulation

(hereafter "Article 16 report");

COMMENDS the work done by the Commission and Member States' authorities in

preparing the Partnership Agreements and the Programmes after the adoption of the

aforementioned Regulation in December 2013;

UNDERLINES the importance of involving relevant partners during the preparation of the

Partnership Agreement and the Programmes, and of continuing this cooperation throughout

the implementation phase;

RECALLS that with a budget of EUR 454 billion for 2014-2020, the European Structural

and Investment Funds (ESI Funds) are the European Union's (EU) main investment tool,

and that by pursuing their economic, social and territorial cohesion objectives, the ESI

Funds play a key role in supporting this investment strategy, and WELCOMES that the

Article 16 report specifically concentrates on results to be achieved, thereby indicating the

strengthened alignment with ESI Funds with the principle of result-orientation, which

could set an example to other policy areas;

NOTES that the expected results to be delivered through the use of ESI-Funds in the

current period are amongst others that more than 2 million enterprises will be supported,

that tens of millions of people will receive support to improve their skills and adaptability

and that large investments in infrastructure will make it possible that less developed

regions will catch up with the rest;

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(6)

Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December

2013 laying down common provisions on the European Regional Development Fund, the

European Social Fund, the Cohesion Fund, the European Agricultural Fund for Rural

Development and the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund and laying down general

provisions on the European Regional Development Fund, the European Social Fund, the

Cohesion Fund and the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund and repealing Council

Regulation (EC) No 1083/2006 (OJ L 347, 20.12.2013, p. 320).

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

(7)

REITERATES the importance of funding from the ESI Funds for co-financing public

investment programmes, which represents a significant and important share of public

investment in some Member States and helps to reduce the investment gap for research and

innovation, sustainable and inclusive growth and regional disparities that, in the aftermath

of the economic crisis still persists;

WELCOMES the alignment of the investments with the priorities of the Europe 2020

strategy and the European Semester, and that the outcome of the negotiations shows a clear

move towards a more focused policy approach, a stronger result orientation, solid

framework conditions for investments, a better coordinated use of ESI Funds through the

Common Strategic Framework and improved links between EU priorities and regional

needs;

NOTES that the support from the ESI Funds represents on average 71 % of the total

programmed 2014-2020 investment; CALLS on the Commission to further analyse the

2014-2020 level of co-financing and the trends compared to previous periods, including

the share of private funding, in order to obtain more information on the provision of

national co-financing and the effects in terms of leverage, impact, and ownership of the

policy on different levels and sources of co-financing;

CALLS on Member States to further encourage the use of private funding, for instance

through the optimal use of Financial Instruments or public-private partnerships, where

appropriate, and seeking complementarity with other instruments such as the European

Fund for Strategic Investments;

WELCOMES the finding that Member States have largely taken into account the relevant

Country Specific Recommendations (CSRs) while preparing the Partnership Agreements

and Programmes and UNDERLINES the importance to continue to align the ESI Funds

with the European Semester, which can indeed be delivered with the help of the ESI

Funds, while taking into account the continuity and stability of the multi-annual

programmes, and STRESSES that in this respect the CSRs need to be relevant, clear and

specific;

(8)

(9)

(10)

(11)

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

(12)

STRESSES the importance of the territorial dimension of cohesion policy and of the ESI

Funds and the role of European Territorial Cooperation in enhancing the economic, social

and territorial potential of regions, in particular border regions, and in reinforcing their

competitiveness, as well as of the continuous, increased focus on the new instruments and

delivery mechanisms such as the Integrated Territorial Investments and the Community-led

local development (CLLD). REGRETS therefore that the analysis of the territorial aspects

and challenges of the ESI Funds is rather limited in the Article 16 report and INVITES the

Commission to provide a deeper analysis in future publications;

WELCOMES that the introduction of the new strategic framework of Partnership

Agreements and Programmes has led to more cross-fund alignment within Member States,

but IS CONCERNED, in light of the lessons learned from the negotiation process, that the

framework may result in unnecessary delays and duplication of work;

EMPHASIZES that the success of the programmes and the corresponding strategies will

depend on good governance and on them starting as early as possible, as well as on their

full implementation in the coming years;

REGRETS the absence of an in-depth analysis, in particular with regard to the process of

setting up the Partnership Agreements and Programmes, as well as with regard to the ex-

ante conditionalities which were not fulfilled at the moment of publication of the Article 16

report; and CALLS therefore on the Commission to:

–

evaluate the abovementioned strategic framework of the Partnership Agreements and

the Programmes, including the preparatory process, and

analyse the ex-ante conditionalities, with emphasis on which conditionalities were

not fulfilled at the moment of publication of the Article 16 report, as well as on the

related Action Plans, in particular with a view to determine underlying bottlenecks in

relation to specific ex-ante conditionalities,

(13)

(14)

(15)

–

having in mind that the result of this evaluation and analysis could have a learning effect

for all stakeholders and feed into the policy discussions on the post-2020 period;

(16)

TAKES NOTE that the country fiches, annexed to the Article 16 report, are based on

evolving data and sought to reflect the state of play at the time of the drafting of the Article

16 report, but REGRETS that Member States were not given an opportunity to review the

data prior to publication and that details on key issues for each Member State cannot be

used for peer-to-peer comparison and learning;

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

(17)

WELCOMES in this context the new ESI Funds Open Data website of the Commission.

HIGHLIGHTS it as a good practice, as it provides for greater transparency of the use and

performance of the ESI Funds without increasing the administrative burden, and

RECOGNISES that the regular submission of data by Member States and their authorities

within the existing regulatory framework will allow the Commission to provide updated

and additional information in the open data platform to be used by Member States for

benchmarking and peer learning;

NOTES that the "High Level Group of Independent Experts on Monitoring Simplification

for Beneficiaries of the European Structural and Investment Funds" identifies good and

best practices, but deems this scope too narrow, REITERATES its demand that

simplification measures should apply to the entire cycle of policy programming and

implementation, taking into consideration the needs of all bodies involved in management

and control and beneficiaries, CALLS upon the Commission to also identify substantial

horizontal issues and INVITES the Commission to regularly inform the Council on its

activities;

REMAINS COMMITTED that a regular debate takes place among relevant ministers in

the Council to discuss the implementation and the results of the ESI Funds."

(18)

(19)

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

OTHER ITEMS APPROVED

GENERAL AFFAIRS

The Council adopted the following conclusions on the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism

(6203/16):

"1.

Reaffirming its earlier conclusions, the Council welcomes the reports from the

Commission on progress in Bulgaria and Romania under the Cooperation and Verification

Mechanism. The Council commends the Commission on its work, on the methodology

followed, and it fully shares the objective and balanced analysis and recommendations

contained in the reports. In this context, the Council appreciates the continued good co-

operation of Bulgaria and Romania with the Commission and with the other Member

States under the Mechanism.

The Council reiterates its adherence to the values and principles of the EU. Effective

implementation of reforms focusing on sustainable results and on convincing and

verifiable track records remains essential for ensuring that citizens are enabled to benefit

fully from all the opportunities offered by membership of the Union. In these regards, the

Council also reiterates the need for broad and unequivocal political support for such

reforms, in order to meet the objectives under the Mechanism.

The Council acknowledges that encouraging steps have been taken to put the reform

process back on track although overall progress in Bulgaria needs to be accelerated

urgently. The senior appointments made in the judiciary are noteworthy. A number of

commendable initiatives, notably the amendment of the Constitution adopted by a broad

majority of Parliament in December 2015, which is a step towards the reform of the

Supreme Judicial Council (SJC), should now be followed up. Ensuring implementation of

the important comprehensive reform strategies on judicial reform and on anti-corruption,

and the monitoring of concrete results will now be key.

While the Council welcomes the political commitment to reforms expressed by the

government, a broader and unequivocal political consensus in support of the reform

process is required to ensure a stronger boost to concrete and sustainable reform efforts.

The Commission's overall assessment reiterates a number of concerns that still need to be

addressed. Bulgaria should focus its efforts on removing controversy about political

influence on the judicial system and integrity issues regarding appointments, as well as the

need to improve on the monitoring and the addressing of deficiencies, and the effective

implementation of court judgements. Pursuing reforms of the Supreme Judicial Council

(SJC) and the prosecution office, and strengthening the powers of the Judicial Inspectorate

(ISJC) remain of key importance. The Council also notes the difficulties with establishing

track records in the areas of combating corruption and organised crime.

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

Building on progress already achieved and existing strategic planning prepared by

Bulgaria, the Council urges a decisive acceleration of efforts to address all the

recommendations set out by the Commission in its report and looks forward to concrete

steps and tangible progress ahead of the next Commission report.

Bulgaria should consolidate and reinforce its overall political resolve to bring about

reforms and make tangible progress, inter alia, by improving and safeguarding the

independence, accountability and integrity of the judiciary, and to pursue the reform of the

judicial system, including an independent analysis of the prosecutor’s office taking into

account the reform measures already implemented. In this regard, particular efforts should

be made to implement the reform of the SJC, to strengthen the ISJC, and to modernise the

criminal legislation. The fight against corruption, in particular at high level, needs to be

intensified, to bring about concrete and sustained results, including in improving the

transparency of public tender procedures. An urgent priority should be to adopt a new anti-

corruption law, which consolidates the intentions set out in the anti-corruption strategy.

This includes the swift establishment of an appropriately funded, unified anti-corruption

authority with a strong independent mandate to fight high-level corruption. As regards

combating organised crime, the efforts should be accelerated, notably through increased

professionalism of law enforcement, and sustained, effective and successful investigations

followed by dissuasive sanctioning, including cooperating with other EU Member States

where appropriate. The Council also notes the importance of swiftly addressing the issues

currently hampering the work of the organised crime directorate (CDCOC) within the

Ministry of Interior, and the Commission for Illegal Assets Forfeiture (CIAF).

The Council commends the continued trend of significant progress demonstrated by

Romania in many areas, which heralds an increasing sustainability of reforms. Action

taken by the key judicial and integrity institutions to address high-level corruption has

maintained an impressive momentum. The professionalism within the Romanian judicial

system as a whole has continued to increase. Overall, the Council considers that Romania,

by maintaining the current positive trends of reform and consolidation of progress and by

internalizing the CVM objectives with national policies and strategies, is on its way to

ensuring the necessary sustainability and irreversibility of reforms which would allow

Romania to attain the objectives of the Mechanism.

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

The Council also reiterates the importance of a broad and unequivocal political

commitment to the reforms by all public institutions and political actors. This is

particularly relevant with regard to the fight against corruption at all levels, to the respect

for the independence of the judiciary, and to other integrity issues highlighted in the report.

The Council notes that open and merit-based appointments to senior positions within the

judiciary, and the scrutiny of candidates for forthcoming elections are a key opportunity to

make further progress in these regards. The Council encourages Romania to swiftly

finalise and adopt the Action Plan 2015-2020 for the implementation of the Strategy for the

Development of the Judiciary 2015-2020 and the development of a new National Anti-

Corruption Strategy.

Building on substantial progress already achieved, the Council encourages Romania to

focus its efforts on further consolidating progress made, and to sustain the current positive

momentum by addressing all the recommendations set out by the Commission in its report.

This would further build towards demonstrating the sustainability of reforms which will

pave the way to satisfactorily fulfil all the benchmarks of the Mechanism in the near future.

Romania should further consolidate progress on ensuring solid respect for, and defence of,

judicial independence. Transparent, robust and merit-based appointments to senior

positions in the magistracy will be a key opportunity to demonstrate further progress.

Pursuit of the judicial reform, including swift adoption of the amendments to the Criminal

code and the Criminal procedure code, in line with what has been presented by the

government, is also of key importance. Court decisions, including those confirming

integrity rulings, should be applied and implemented by all institutions and instances

without delay, including the Romanian parliament. Further sustained efforts to prevent and

tackle corruption, including addressing it effectively and dissuasively at all levels and

within all institutions, remain a top priority.

The Council reiterates that the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism continues to be

instrumental for progress. It remains an appropriate tool to assist both Member States in

their respective reform efforts, in order for each of them to achieve a record of concrete

and lasting results to reach the objectives of the Mechanism. The Council recalls its

readiness to support efforts of Bulgaria and Romania in this regard through EU and

bilateral assistance. Pending the results expected from each of the two Member States in

this framework, the Mechanism stays in place. In this context, the Council looks forward to

the next Commission reports on Bulgaria and Romania foreseen within a year’s time and

welcomes the Commission’s intention to continue monitoring the situation in Bulgaria and

Romania closely and to keep the Council regularly informed."

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS

EU emergency support for Greece

The Council adopted a regulation setting up an EU emergency support mechanism to help Greece

and other member states overwhelmed by the arrival of large numbers of refugees (6977/16 +

7009/16 ADD 1).

This follows the political agreement reached by the Council's Permanent

Representatives Committee on 9 March 2016. It enables the EU to provide a timely and effective

response to the very difficult situation that is rapidly developing on the ground.

For details, see

press release.

Schengen Evaluation Mechanism - Belgium

The Council adopted two implementing decisions setting out recommendations on addressing the

deficiencies identified in the 2015 evaluation of the application by Belgium of the Schengen acquis

in the field of return (6691/16) and of the common visa policy (6688/16).

Schengen Evaluation Mechanism - Sweden

The Council adopted an implementing decision setting out a recommendation on addressing the

deficiencies identified in the evaluation of Sweden's application of the Schengen acquis in the field

of management of the external borders (6686/16)

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

FOOD LAW

Food additives and food flavourings

The Council decided not to oppose the adoption of the following three Commission regulations:

–

a regulation authorising the use of calcium propionate (E282) as a preservative in tortillas

to extend their shelf-life (6315/16)

a regulation establishing a food category 'edible caseinates' in the regulation setting out an

EU list of additives approved for use in food (6365/16)

a regulation listing seven food flavourings as evaluated substances rather than substances

under evaluation (6366/16)

–

The Commission regulations are subject to the 'regulatory procedure with scrutiny'. This means that

now that the Council has given its consent, the Commission may adopt them, unless the European

Parliament objects.

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

TRANSPORT

International Maritime Organisation: positions to be adopted on behalf of the EU

The Council adopted a decision on the position to be taken on behalf of the EU at the following

meetings to be held in the framework of the International Maritime Organisation (IMO):

–

the 40

session of the Facilitation Committee (FAL 40) on 4–8 April 2016, with regard to

amendments to the 1965 Convention on Facilitation of International Maritime Traffic

('FAL Convention')

the 69

session of the Marine Environment Protection Committee (MEPC 69) on 18–22

April 2016, with regard to amendments to Annex IV to the International Convention for

the Prevention of Pollution from Ships ('MARPOL Annex IV'), Regulations 1 and 11,

setting the effective dates for part of the Baltic Sea to be designated as a Special Area for

the purpose of preventing pollution by sewage from ships

the 96

session of the Maritime Safety Committee (MSC 96) on 11–20 May 2016, with

regard to amendments to Regulations II-2/13 and II-2/18 of the International Convention

for the Safety of Life at Sea ('SOLAS'), the International Code for Fire Safety Systems

('FSS Code') and the 2011 Enhanced Survey Programme Code (the '2011 ESP Code').

–

7101/16

Rådsmøde nr. 3458 (almindelige anliggender) den 15. marts 2016 - Bilag 1336865:

15 March 2016

EMPLOYMENT

EURES

The Council adopted a regulation (6421/16) on the re-establishment and reorganisation of the

existing EURES (EURopean Employment Services) network.

The improved network assists workers in overcoming barriers to mobility, increases access to

employment opportunities throughout the EU and helps to facilitate job creation. It contributes to

tackling unemployment by helping to better match supply and demand in the labour market.

CUSTOMS UNION

Moldova - Euro-Mediterranean agreement - Rules of origin

The Council approved a

decision

on the position to be taken by the EU with a view to updating the

concept of 'originating products' and methods of administrative cooperation, within the Euro-

Mediterranean agreement with Moldova.

7101/16